TSA & Shoes – Blind, incompetent, and stupid

Just flew up to Anchorage and back on Alaska Airlines. It’s pretty much a monthly exercise in what Bruce Schneier refers to as “security theater”. [Note: Schneier’s blog, Schneier on Security, is a must read antidote to TSA.] It boggles the mind how some incompetent decided that using an uncalibrated x-ray scanner was an effective way to detect explosives. Without a densitometer or an IQI run at the same time as the scanned article, all the x-ray scanner does is provide a rough differentiation based upon density. So any material of approximately the same density as an explosive material, say C-4, shows up on the scanner looking like C-4, leading to either a unacceptably high level of false positives or a significant possibility of failure to detect. If it’s not shaped like a weapon, it will probably pass unnoticed.

And of course, you have to take your shoes off. After x-raying millions of shoes, TSA declared that they had a winner! Some unfortunate bloke in Anchorage won the “special treatment” after TSA found a toggle switch in his/her shoe.

TSA_Shoe1 Here’s the winning pair, courtesy of TSA…

TSA_Shoe2 Here’s the scary bomb parts…

OK, so found the proverbial needle in a haystack. Listen carefully… by itself, it doesn’t mean shit. The inference that TSA would like to impart is that the switch and wire is part of a nefarious terrorist plot. That is an unfounded inference, without merit. Without corroborating information, a toggle switch is just a toggle switch.

Why would someone have a toggle switch on a length of wire in their shoe? Ah, let me count the ways:

  • This was in Anchorage, Alaska. What happens when you’re out in the bush and your snowmobile has a frozen ignition because it’s -40? You carry a toggle switch and wire with you to bypass the ignition so you can get home before you freeze to death.
  • You’re a forgetful car thief, and forgot that you had that wire and switch to bypass car alarms in your shoe.
  • You shoplifted Radio Shack on the way to the airport.
  • You work in an electronics supply store and pilfered some parts for your home computer.
  • You’re a really stupid terrorist wannabe trying to see what you can get away with.
  • You’re a really stupid terrorist.

Notice that there is only one possible line of reasoning that is a terrorist, but several that don’t. So the probability is quite high (83% or higher) that the shoes do not belong to a terrorist.

[Update – 23 March 2008] – I posted basically the same information on the TSA blog a few days before this post. As of today, my blog comments to their shoe security is still unposted. Maybe TSA doesn’t like being told that their basic premises are flawed?

This entry was posted in airport security, TSA and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to TSA & Shoes – Blind, incompetent, and stupid

  1. Mike says:

    OK Here you go. Please look up a guy called Richard Reed. A toggle switch and wires inside a shoe. So do you know what explosives look like on their xray machines. You can find examples on google images. they look like green or orange blobs so if I saw that with your wire and toggle switch then yes I am stopping you if I am a TSA guy. Think about it a little bit before educate yourself a little you just pop off on a blog on the internet.

    • wilco278 says:

      Richard Reed – a couple ounces of explosive, det cord, and a match. Not a toggle switch and wires. Also notice that the wires and toggle switch are not connected. And no explosive. The point that I was trying to make is that TSA is assuming that everything that could be a weapon is assumed to be a weapon, whether it is a bottle of water, a screwdriver, or a toggle switch. There is no risk analysis being done, they’re merely applying paranoid movie plots to reality.
      As far as educating myself, I used to be certified to do non-destructive examinations of piping, using x-rays, among other methods. The work included x-ray machine calibration. That’s why I know a little about densitometers and IQIs for calibrating scanners. Yes, I have seen explosives on x-rays. They’re roughly the same shade of density as dense hardwood. The colors are artificial, based upon density readings.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s